by Jne_K on Tue May 22, 2012 6:59 am
I've tested and seen both and you are right - there is no clear winner. It's really going to boil down to which you like better in your hands and only you can answer that. Some impressions.
The Swarovski flat field eyepieces are impressive. They do provide a different viewing experience than the older Els. You could get hooked on that feature, alone, quite easily. Truly a breathtaking viewing experience. Lastly, although the open bridge, EL design has been much copied, I still don't think you can beat the way any EL feels in the hand. They are distinctive in that regard.
The EDG is a heavy binocular in the hands, by comparison, at least for me, but it is built like a tank. Optics are Nikon's best. Edge sharpness and complete lack of eye strain is noteworthy. Crisp, sharp, and color correct across the entire field of view - about as technically perfect as binocular optics can be, in my book.
You really do owe it to yourself to put both of these fine binoculars in your hands
I've tested and seen both and you are right - there is no clear winner. It's really going to boil down to which you like better in your hands and only you can answer that. Some impressions.
The Swarovski flat field eyepieces are impressive. They do provide a different viewing experience than the older Els. You could get hooked on that feature, alone, quite easily. Truly a breathtaking viewing experience. Lastly, although the open bridge, EL design has been much copied, I still don't think you can beat the way any EL feels in the hand. They are distinctive in that regard.
The EDG is a heavy binocular in the hands, by comparison, at least for me, but it is built like a tank. Optics are Nikon's best. Edge sharpness and complete lack of eye strain is noteworthy. Crisp, sharp, and color correct across the entire field of view - about as technically perfect as binocular optics can be, in my book.
You really do owe it to yourself to put both of these fine binoculars in your hands