Beautiful boots but odd - Danner Bull Run Chelsea 6in Height Shoes - Women's

I loved how they looked when i received them but the sizing is way off. I normally wear an 8.5 medium in most shoes. So thats what I ordered but they were way too long in the toe, and narrow. So i had to go down a full size to 7.5, while they are long enough in the toe, even longer than needed, they are very narrow and pinch my toes. The only way to comfortably wear them is by taking out the insoles but then they aren’t very supportive. Also the leather on the right boot isn’t wearing well, it looks all wrinkled and odd while the leather on the left still looks good after only one month of wear. I am very disappointed because these boots were very expensive.