This was my first paddle holster and (compared to fobus belt holsters, which are very uncomfortable, I believe) found it to be very, very, comfortable and secure. I do not have a problem with the modified draw stroke to suit the weapon light. The only drawback would be concealability, since from what I can tell all fobus ride quite far out from the waistband, which causes a comfort problem when without the support of a very rigid paddle like this one. Great for open carry environments. Like I said, it does not fit the PX4 as advertised, but fits my M&P .40 perfectly.
Pros: comfort, usability
Cons: does not fit PX4, not concealable
This review was written in the old system and had content requirements that are different than reviews written today.