Better than stock but rattles - Magpul Industries CTR Mil-Spec AR15/M16 AR Collapsible Buttstock

It's better than the stock one that came on my Sport2. I ordered this one after reading all the reviews about how it doesn't rattle like the original one does. I must say this one looks nicer and I like the rubber butt pad but the Magpul CTR has just as much slack and rattle as my S&W. I'm a bit disappointed in this one. It's an upgrade from OEM but not what I was expecting. I did check to make sure I received the correct one and the box does say for mil spec tube so I guess that's just how it is.