Not sure how this slide is highly rated - Patmos Arms Judah Glock G23 Slide

Received this Judah G23 slide and immediately noticed the uneven finish compared to other aftermarket slides, or Glock OEM slides. Looks quite a bit better in the pictures than it does when you see it in person. I know this probably doesn't bother a lot of people, especially for the price, but I decided to return it because of the cheap look and feel, and instead found a good used OEM G23 slide with the excellent Gen 3 "frying pan" finish. I paid more, actually about double this slide, but I feel it's worth it to get OEM quality. Lesson learned.