Can't be beat - Safariland 6360 ALS Level III w/ Ride UBL Holster - Nylon-Look, Right Hand 6360-4192-261

I think this is the best light bearing holster out there. It is durable, has plenty of options, and provides a natural draw stroke while simultaneously releasing retention devices, yet it's incredibly secure from a takeaway,

There's a reason these are the most widely used holsters.
Pros: Smooth draw, durable, perfect fit
Cons: None (just wish it was cheaper, but who doesn't)

This review was written in the old system and had content requirements that are different than reviews written today.