The Fobus Roto-Tactical holster is a unique holster because it can incorporate any light or laser that is rail mounted. The Roto-Tactical holster fits a variety of firearms. If you have different guns, you can use the same holster for it. The one I purchased fits the S&W M&P9, M&P40, and also the full size M&P45. I found this holster to be a great value. It takes a little getting used to but requires much less training than other holster systems out there. My only concern with the holster is retention from backward grabs. I think the leather button strap will suffice as a secure way to carry a weapon however. For concealed carry the retention concerns I have are small. As a police officer you would most likely want a holster with higher security than this. How is the comfort? Compared to Blackhawk Serpa holsters, the paddle configuration is much more comfortable and it takes up less space on the belt. With a Serpa holster, the paddle goes from 1 or 2 o'clock all the way to 5. For people who carry a lot on their belts, that isn't practical. The Fobus paddle can be worn comfortably anywhere on your belt besides at the 12 o'clock position. The holster is very durable and completely maintenance free. I can draw my handgun as fast or faster than I can with a Blackhawk! Serpa Level II holster. I recommend this holster as a well made, affordable holster.
My only concern is the drawing motion and potential retention concerns. If you don't have a problem with that, buy it and enjoy it!
Pros: The holster fits a few different models of firearms. It fits any light/laser. Addresses some retention concerns. Very fast to draw.
Cons: Can be easy to get out of the holster by a bad guy. Can take some training to get used to.
This review was written in the old system and had content requirements that are different than reviews written today.