1 works, 1 defective - Pachmayr Competition Speed Loader 5-Shot S&W J Frame/Ruger LCR, Ruger SP101/Taurus 85/ Rossi 68

I ordered 2 of these, and one works, the other works but does not hold the bullets snugly. The good unit has an o-ring installed in the base that presses against the bottom of the bullets when the release is locked to hold. The bad unit is missing this o-ring so the lock holds the bullets but they are not immobilized and have a good couple millimeters play in their seats.

The good unit is perfect and works well, and the bad unit works but is really annoying when the bullets are rattling around in their seats.