No barrel nut with the tacstar - but still a win - TacStar Carbon Fiber AR-15 Handguard

The TacStar Carbon Fiber Mid-Length Handguard is an excellent choice, offering serious weight savings without compromising feel or rigidity. The carbon fiber texture is fantastic—it has a solid, premium grip and stays remarkably cool, even during extended range sessions. Installation was straightforward, and it really modernized the look of my rifle. I’m docking one star because, surprisingly, a barrel nut was not included in the package, which meant an extra step to source one before installation. Also, the M-LOK slots felt a little tighter than usual on one side, requiring a bit more force to seat accessories initially. However, once installed, everything is rock-solid. For the price and the significant weight reduction you get, this handguard is a clear winner and a great upgrade.